The same cycle happens over and over again.
A globally renowned pop-star releases another chart-topping album. To accompany this? A world tour. Buried amongst the long lines of tour destinations and dates, suddenly, a location close to home appears.
Kuala Lumpur.
The same cycle happens over and over again.
Social media is set ablaze, with comments on the tour announcement flooding the names of different countries and cities. Tabloids publish articles, spanning such vast topics from the set-list, possible surprise guests, to sensationalised topics. Friends, spamming messages to each other, planning out which dates to clear, which form of transportation they will use, which category to sit in.
The same cycle happens over and over again.
When tickets finally go on sale, the bots are activated, snagging tickets from passionate listeners, just to re-sell on the second-hand market for out-of-the-world price hikes. The website crashes, queues reset, seats marked as sold even when they aren’t.
The same cycle happens over and over again.
Then, the promoters, seeing the large influx of money, decide to open up one more night.
The earlier exclusivity of the tickets?
Gone.
Yet, even if more nights are opened, and more shows are completely sold-out, the same cycle happens over and over again.

[The Billboard Hot 100 Chart, from Billboard]
Chapter 1: Humble Beginnings
Like every event, the primary mode of facilitating the entry of devout fans to their beloved artists’ live performance is by tickets. Yet, the entire ticketing system, from the securing of artists via promoters, to the booking of large stadium venues, to the selling and printing of tickets, is considered a legal monopoly.
So, how did we get here? And why is it a monopoly?
In a recent lawsuit, United States v. Live Nation Entertainment, the ticketing giant Live Nation, was found liable to be a legal monopoly, which violated both federal and state antitrust laws in the United States. As a result, the States involved in this legal battle wants a federal judge to order a corporate breakup of the two behemoths involved in their merged conglomerate, Ticketmaster and Live Nation.
First of all, what is Ticketmaster?

[An example of ticket purchasing, from Ticketmaster]
Ticketmaster is a ticketing service based in the United States, which has just recently marked its 50th anniversary as a company. The company began with humble origins, being founded in Phoenix, Arizona by two college staffers and a businessman. Soon after, their corporate headquarters was moved to Los Angeles, signaling an interest to be geographically closer to the entertainment industry.
Diversifying from their origins of selling ticketing hardware and licensed computer software, Ticketmaster began slowly expanding its influence by acquiring contracts with well-known venues within Los Angeles. Under their CEO during this period, Fred Rosen, Ticketmaster started eyeing up the publishing business, and acquired their competitor in the ticketing space, Ticketron, in 1991.
After this acquisition, Ticketmaster moved to be the market leader for the ticketing industry. After many more acquisitions with businesses involved with ticketing, such as ticketing systems, artist management firms, ticket resellers, Ticketmaster soared to the top and became the most resourced and connected firm in the ticketing industry.
Finally, in February 2009, Ticketmaster agreed to undergo a corporate merger with another industry titan, Live Nation.

[A snippet of an article regarding this merger, by The Guardian]
Live Nation began as a subsidiary company, acquiring a roster of concert promoters, while also acquiring several businesses involved within the music industry. After a long game of acquisitions and selling, Live Nation became the dominant force within the promoting industry, and approached Ticketmaster with an irresistible idea.
Why don’t we merge?
In an astounding 2.5 billion dollar, all-stock deal, the two companies merged to form Live Nation Entertainment, the familiar mega-corporation and monopoly we know today. However, during this process of merging, there were several regulatory roadblocks trying to prevent this antitrust merger from occurring.
While both Norway and Turkey gave the green-light, the United Kingdom’s antitrust regulator, the Competition Commission, initially viewed this merger negatively, as the merger of two highly-specialised corporations breeds a higher chance of breaking antitrust laws. Yet, after only 2 months of deliberation, the Commission cleared the merger, leading the way for this proposition to receive one final approval from the most important oversight board – the United States Department of Justice.
On conditions of approval, the newly-formed Live Nation Entertainment had to allow the Ticketmaster software to be used by their market rivals, Anschutz Entertainment. Yet, even with the “availability” of the Ticketmaster software being widespread, the power of a corporation being able to manage the frontend (ticketing) and the backend (artist recruitment and promotion), a monopoly is sure to form.
This brings us back to the present, where ticket prices are sky-high, fees are abundant and expensive, websites are floppy, queues are unstable and untrustworthy, bots roam freely amongst the sea of passionate listeners.
Inherently, monopolies lead to worse consumer experiences. When a consumer only has one outlet to purchase something they want, there is no expectation to keep the outlet up-to-date. From software data leaks, to the lack of oversight when it comes to third-party ticketing services, to the increasing amount of tickets being resold for daylight robbery prices on exchanges like StubHub, a monopoly in ticketing software results in a loss for the fan, but gains for the companies.
Ticket prices are sky high, so artists must earn more right?
Chapter 2: Artist for Hire
When you pay such exorbitant prices for a ticket, the first thought is:
“Oh, I am directly supporting my favourite artist financially!”
This is crucial for more independent artists, compared to the world-renowned superstars whose name already attracts money like a magnet to iron filings. But, the contrast of earnings between an independent artist and a superstar is a match-up even more unfair than that of David and Goliath.
So, let us break down the data, and analyse this for ourselves.
For this analysis, I will introduce two of my favourite artists, one being more independent, while the other being a pop-star. So, for the more independent artist, we will focus on New West (whose song titled “Next to You” is my absolute favourite), while for the pop-star, we shift our sights to the stars, as we look at Taylor Swift.
Now, we can start off with New West.

[A promotional photo of New West, from Live Nation]
Analysis: New West
For New West, they most recently embarked on a North America only tour last year, headlining in 24 cities across the countries of Canada and the United States. After their breakout hit “Those Eyes”, accompanied by the catalyst for music artists that is TikTok, New West scaled up their live presence immensely throughout this tour.

[A Promotional Poster for New West’s North American Tour, found online]
It is time for some mathematics.
By estimating the venues to be similar to Toronto’s Concert Hall, we can expect a 1000 person capacity on the low-end, and a 1500 person capacity on the high-end. Across the tour, with an estimated 90% fill rate (the percentage of the venue being filled) and a ticket price of around 35 dollars, we can plug all of this information into a calculator.
For the high end, we do 1500 multiplied by 90%, then multiplied by 35, then multiplied by 24 to get estimated revenue for the whole tour, which is 1.13 million dollars. For the low-end, however, the estimated revenue is 756 thousand dollars. Additionally, we can factor in merchandise sales and its profits, leaving us with 856 thousand dollars on the low-end, and 1.23 million dollars on the high end. Sounds fantastic, right?
Yet, this revenue does not mean profit straight away.
A tour of this magnitude requires a full team of supporting personnel, from the promoting agent securing the venue bookings, to the tour-bus drivers, to background musicians. Every aspect of a tour, especially for an independent artist, is financially taxing. Furthermore, more expenses will be accrued from costs relating to venue bookings, to agent and ticketing cuts, to necessities like food and fuel.
So, let us take some liberal estimates.
For a tour of this size, we can assume that the booking agent and band management takes around 20% of the gross revenue (roughly being 140 thousand dollars), while venue related costs takes around 20% of the same gross revenue too (being 140 thousand dollars), to costs pertaining to food and logistics (estimated to 500 thousand dollars), and fees for hired musicians (being around 100 thousand dollars). So, how much does New West actually rake in?
350 thousand dollars.

[A Sankey Diagram of Estimated Revenue for New West, by me]
Are there more expenditures after this?
Of course!
The generated profit here has to first be split amongst the record labels and advertising if applicable. Then only is the remaining fraction of the money split amongst core band members.
After 24 gruelling concert days in different venues all around North America, traversing across two of the largest countries by land, members of New West only receive five figures in profit.
In our minds, this sounds like a lot of money, but relative to other well-known artists, it is all but a drop in the bucket.
Now, how does Taylor Swift fare?
Analysis: Taylor Swift
For Taylor Swift, however, her name itself can be used as a marketing gimmick. Looking back at her most consequential tour, the Eras Tour, across an astounding 149 sold-out shows, she managed to generate a record-breaking 2.08 billion dollars, a difference of over 3 orders of magnitude relative to New West. Her earnings surpassed 660 million dollars, comfortably making her a billionaire, solely because of this tour.

[A photo of Taylor Swift performing on her Eras Tour, by Rolling Stone]
Yet, even with an artist of such calibre, the same issues appeared throughout the ticketing process for her tour as well.
From crashing websites to scalpers running away with sky-high markups, tickets to the Eras Tour were not immune from the same negative experience associated with ticketing services, however the main difference between an artist like New West and Taylor Swift are the fans.
There was a whole controversy associated with the acquisition of tickets for this tour, but what is the cause of this fiasco?
Ticketmaster has a programme called the “Verified Fan Pre-Sale”, which allows the registered fans to buy tickets a few days before the actual general sale. Due to her immense popularity, there was a record-shattering 3.5 million confirmed “Verified Fans” preparing for the battle which was ticket sales.
When the sale came online, another record-breaking statistic emerged. A whopping 2.4 million tickets were sold, causing heavy website-traffic as a historically unprecedented event intersected with an aged, monopolised, sub-standard software.
But, after the fiasco of crashing websites and frozen queues, Live Nation then decided to cancel the general sale due to “insufficient inventory” accompanied by an apology for the other fans who were unable to get a ticket. Due to her stardom, Swift’s fans ranged from many different professions and backgrounds, which resulted in the mobilisation of lawyers and other officials with antitrust experience to collect complaints for the American Federal Trade Commission and state attorneys generals.
After wide-spread complaints on social media, this issue also rallied up several law-makers, ultimately resulting in a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing where the representative from Live Nation was torched by sitting senators, in a move where politically-divided senators were united together in their staunch distaste for the monopolistic nature of Live Nation.

[A Sankey Diagram of Estimated Revenue for Taylor Swift, from Reddit]
The resulting action from this hearing directly led to the lawsuit against Live Nation mentioned earlier, where Live Nation was found guilty of being a monopoly, pending further punishments or appeals.
On the contrary, the difference in influence of artists can be vividly shown by the comparison of the two artists. For an artist with such influence as Taylor Swift, her fiasco with Ticketmaster was the straw which broke the camel’s back on the growing dissatisfaction with Live Nation. But, for other artists who do not have such a strong following, they have to suck it up and accept the charges Live Nation levy (since they control every aspect of the tour, from the setting-up, to the venues, to the tickets) while also calming the intense embers of frustration of their avid listeners.
This results in one question.
Are artists for hire?
Conclusion: A Ticket to You
Through the tales of frozen websites, lagged-out queues and bots, there is still one consistency underpinning the successful tour of any artist.
The avid fan.
Even with the strong deterrent of knowing that ticket acquisition itself will involve queueing, clicking that button which says “I’m still here” every 5 minutes, completing CAPTCHAs endlessly until finally the system realises you’re a human, seeing the progression queue move super slowly on your computer while blaring fast on your phone, the avid fan still goes through this to be able to physically support their favourite artist.
When tickets are sold on the second-hand market, selling for prices leagues above the original sell price, the purchasers will only be the most avid listeners, willing to spend extra just to see their favourite artist perform live.

[An example Seating Map, from Go-Live Asia]
However, looking back at concerts and performances, there is still one more thing to consider, what about the venue?
For a normal concert, there are different types of tickets, known as categories (or CATs), and the usual difference between CATs are:
- Price (ranging from RM300 to expensive box tickets being above RM1000)
- Mode of experience (from standing, to seating, to boxes)
Concerts make the most money for standing tickets, by compressing groups of devoted fans into a rectangle which is drawn out with stanchions. This then results in an experience where the fan might feel compressed, with little personal space as people around them are shoulder-to-shoulder, but it results in the promoters being able to sell more tickets.
Then, the queue just to enter the venue?
Unhinged.
Arriving hours earlier than the actual ticket entry time does not help, as there always are people earlier, or people with exclusive VIP privileges who enjoy expedited check-in, and expedited checks, going into a hall where there are sound-checks, and other expensive benefits.
So, what does a ticket for you do?
A ticket for a concert is itself the biggest appreciation of the arts.
A ticket shows that you are willing to fight monopolised services filled with bots and sub-standard website services for a chance to listen to your favourite artist.
A ticket shows that you are willing to queue for ages, so that you can enter the hall, for the chance to listen to your favorite artist.
A ticket shows that you are willing to pay expensive (if not extortionate prices on the second-hand market) prices for the chance to listen to your favorite artist.
Then, to conclude this article,
What does a ticket mean for you?
Written By: Dylan
Edited By: Yu Xin
